On this page
- You've Been Paying Workers as 1099s. Now You're Not So Sure.
- What the IRS Offers: VCSP and Section 530
- Why Federal Relief Doesn't Help You in California
- Here’s an Example of What Proactive Looks Like
- The Core Mistake
- California: EDD and FTB Are Their Own World
- What to Actually Do: Your Path Forward
- Why It Matters
- Ready to Clean It Up? NCO Can Help.
- You can proactively reclassify workers before an audit, and doing so on your own terms is almost always better than waiting.
- The IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) reduces federal back taxes for eligible employers, but it doesn't touch California.
- Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 can protect you from federal penalties if you had a reasonable basis for the classification, but again, California doesn't recognize it.
- California's Employment Development Department (EDD) and Franchise Tax Board (FTB) operate independently from the IRS, with no equivalent relief program.
- NCO can handle payroll setup and corrected filings. For the legal and compliance side, you'll want an employment attorney.
You've Been Paying Workers as 1099s. Now You're Not So Sure.
Maybe you got a letter from the EDD. Maybe your accountant flagged something. Maybe you just read about AB 5 and did the math. Whatever the trigger, you're now asking a question a lot of California business owners eventually face: what happens if those contractors were actually employees?
The short answer is you have options. The longer answer is those options look very different depending on whether you act now or wait for an audit.
This post walks you through both the federal programs available and why California is its own separate situation entirely.
What the IRS Offers: VCSP and Section 530
The federal government has two main relief mechanisms for worker misclassification. Understanding what they cover, and what they don't, is the starting point.
The Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP) is an IRS program that lets employers voluntarily reclassify workers as employees going forward. In exchange for doing so, you pay a reduced amount equal to about 10% of the employment taxes that would have been owed on the workers' compensation for the most recent tax year. You also get limited audit protection for prior years.
To qualify for the VCSP, you must meet these conditions:
- you've been consistently treating the workers as non-employees
- you've filed the required 1099s, and you're not currently under audit by the IRS, EDD, or Department of Labor (DOL), and you haven't previously been audited by the EDD for worker classification.
Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 is different. It's not a program you apply for. It's a legal defense.
If you had a "reasonable basis" for treating workers as contractors (a prior audit with no reclassification, industry practice, a legal opinion, or other reasonable grounds), Section 530 can shield you from federal employment tax liability.
The critical word in both of those descriptions is "federal."
Why Federal Relief Doesn't Help You in California
The VCSP and Section 530 apply to IRS liability only. California has its own agencies, its own rules, and its own enforcement. Neither program has any effect on what you might owe the EDD or FTB.
The EDD handles unemployment insurance, state disability insurance, and employment training taxes. If your workers should have been on payroll, the EDD can assess back taxes plus penalties and interest, regardless of any IRS settlement you've reached.
The FTB handles state income tax withholding. Same situation: a federal resolution doesn't satisfy FTB exposure.
California also has no state-level equivalent to the VCSP. There's no voluntary settlement program you can use to limit EDD or FTB liability proactively. What you can do is get ahead of it, before an audit starts, by reclassifying on your own and correcting past filings where appropriate.
Here’s an Example of What Proactive Looks Like
A restaurant owner in Sacramento had been paying her kitchen manager as a 1099 contractor for three years. The arrangement made sense at first, but the manager had become full-time, worked fixed hours, and used equipment the owner provided.
When she started looking at expansion and talked to her CPA, the classification issue surfaced. Under California's ABC test, Part B was the problem: a kitchen manager performs work that is squarely within the usual course of a restaurant's business. Food preparation and kitchen operations are what a restaurant does. The manager didn't qualify as a contractor under the ABC test, regardless of how the arrangement started. She hadn't been audited. She wasn't under investigation. But the exposure was real.
She applied for the VCSP to resolve federal liability, reclassified the manager as an employee going forward, and worked with an employment attorney to assess her EDD exposure. The attorney helped her file corrected returns and negotiate the state back taxes. Her payroll provider set up proper withholding from that point forward.
The total cost was real, but manageable. She controlled the timeline. She avoided penalties that come with an audit finding. And she started 2025 with a clean payroll setup.
Compare that to a business owner who waited: EDD audit, full back taxes assessed for multiple years, penalties on top, and no ability to negotiate proactively.
The Core Mistake
Assuming federal relief covers your California exposure is the fastest way to underprepare.
California: EDD and FTB Are Their Own World
California applies one of the strictest worker classification tests in the country. The ABC test, established under AB 5, presumes every worker is an employee unless the hiring business can prove all three prongs: the worker is free from the company's control, the work is outside the company's usual business, and the worker is in an independently established trade.
Many arrangements that look like legitimate contractor relationships under federal common law don't pass the ABC test. That's why California's EDD exposure is often larger than the federal exposure for the same misclassification.
The EDD audits employers for payroll tax compliance. It has broad subpoena authority, can go back three or more years, and can assess penalties on top of back taxes. The FTB can assess separately for withholding failures.
There is no amnesty program at the state level. Getting ahead of it means doing the work yourself, before they show up.
What to Actually Do: Your Path Forward
- Audit your contractor relationships. Go through each 1099 worker. How much control does your business have over how and when they work? Do they work exclusively (or primarily) for you? Do they use your equipment? Do they work in your core business? If the answers point toward employment, treat it that way.
- Apply for the VCSP if you qualify. Check the IRS eligibility requirements. If you haven't been audited and have filed your 1099s, you may qualify. This handles the federal side.
- Bring in an employment attorney for the California piece. This is where legal counsel earns its fee. An attorney can assess your EDD and FTB exposure, help you file corrected returns strategically, and represent you if the EDD questions any part of the reclassification.
- Set up payroll correctly going forward. Once you've decided to reclassify, you need payroll infrastructure: withholding, employer contributions, quarterly filings. This is table stakes, and it's worth doing right.
- File corrected W-2s and 1099s where needed. If workers received 1099s who should have received W-2s, corrected filings are part of the cleanup. The scope and timing depends on your specific situation.
- Document your reasoning for any contractors you're keeping. For anyone you're continuing to classify as a contractor, make sure the relationship actually holds up under California's ABC test. Document why.
Why It Matters
Worker misclassification is one of the most common and most expensive payroll mistakes for California businesses. The EDD has been increasing audit activity, and the penalties compound fast: back taxes, interest, failure-to-file penalties, and in some cases personal liability for business owners.
The cost of getting ahead of it, even when there's real back tax exposure, is almost always lower than the cost of being found in an audit.
This is one of those situations where acting early matters.
Ready to Clean It Up? NCO Can Help.
If you've decided to reclassify workers (or you're still figuring out where you stand), here's how NCO fits in.
We handle payroll setup for newly reclassified employees: employer account registration, withholding setup, and ongoing compliance. We also prepare corrected 1099s and W-2s as part of the cleanup process.
What we don't do: legal analysis of your EDD or FTB exposure, representation in audits, or employment law advice. For that piece, you need an employment attorney, and we're glad to refer you to someone.
If you want to start with the payroll side and get your books in order, reach out to NCO. We'll get your payroll set up properly from day one.


