Does Your Business Need a Holding Company to Save on Taxes?

Nguyen & Company, CPA6 min read
On this page
  1. 01When It's the Wrong Move
  2. 02When It's the Right Move
  3. 03Quick Checklist
Key takeaways
  • A holding company and extra entities add yearly fees, tax returns, and bookkeeping, and for most owners with one business those costs are higher than any tax they save.
  • Add an entity when it protects a valuable asset, separates partners, or prepares part of your business for sale, and keep everything else in one well-run entity.

You've probably seen a video or post saying every business owner needs a holding company and several LLCs to cut their taxes. For a business with one owner and one line of work, that structure usually costs more each year in fees, tax returns, and bookkeeping than it saves in tax. Multiple entities earn their cost when they protect a valuable asset, separate owners, or prepare part of the business for sale. Knowing which situation you're in can save you thousands of dollars a year.

When It's the Wrong Move

Your profit still sits on one tax return

An entity is a legal business, like a limited liability company (LLC) or a corporation. A holding company is an entity that owns other entities instead of running a business itself.

Most small businesses are pass-through entities, meaning the business pays no federal income tax and its profit is taxed on the owner's personal return. LLCs and S corporations work this way. If you own three pass-through entities, all three profits land on the same personal return. Moving income between them changes which entity reports it, and your total tax stays the same.

Every entity adds a yearly cost

Each new entity needs its own filings, its own tax return, and its own books for every year it exists.

CostWhat it adds each year
California annual tax$800 per LLC or corporation, whether or not it makes a profit (ftb.ca.gov)
California LLC fee$0 to $11,790, based on the LLC's California income (ftb.ca.gov)
Business tax returnsAverage fees of $733 for a partnership return and $903 for an S corporation return (National Society of Accountants, 2020–2021 survey)
BookkeepingA second set of books, monthly reconciliations, and tracking every payment between entities
Banking and softwareA separate bank account and accounting software subscription for each entity
LegalOperating agreements and written contracts between entities, updated when anything changes

These costs repeat every year, whether or not the entity saves you anything.

A structure set up the wrong way can raise your taxes

Only individuals, estates, and certain trusts can own shares in an S corporation. If a holding company taxed as a partnership or corporation owns your S corporation's shares, the S election ends (IRS, S Corporations).

Management fees paid between your own entities can also move profit into an LLC where it's subject to self-employment tax, the Social Security and Medicare tax on business income. When the same person owns several businesses, the IRS can reassign income between them if the prices they charge each other don't match what unrelated businesses would charge (Internal Revenue Code Section 482).

Example: A Torrance Physical Therapy Clinic

Before: A Torrance physical therapy clinic had $1.2 million in revenue and ran as an S corporation. After following online advice, the owner added a holding LLC to own the clinic, a management LLC that charged the clinic $300,000 a year in fees, and an equipment LLC that leased equipment back to the clinic. The three new LLCs added $2,400 in California annual tax, a $900 LLC fee for the management company, about $1,500 in extra tax returns, and $6,000 in extra bookkeeping. That came to $10,800 a year, plus $4,500 in one-time legal fees. The tax saved was zero, because all three LLCs reported to the same personal return as the clinic's profit. The management fees also moved $300,000 into an LLC where it was subject to self-employment tax.

The fix: The owner and the accountant compared the yearly cost of each entity with the tax it saved, and closed all three LLCs (process). The clinic went back to one set of books and one business bank account (systems). The owner now reviews any new entity with the accountant before forming it (people).

The result: The clinic saves about $10,800 a year in fees and filings, pays the same income tax as before, and no longer pays self-employment tax on management fees.

When It's the Right Move

Multiple entities earn their cost when they solve a problem one entity can't. In most cases, that problem is about protecting assets or separating owners, and tax savings are a smaller part of the decision.

You own real estate or expensive equipment

Holding a building in its own LLC and leasing it to your business separates the building from your day-to-day business risks. A claim against the business is generally limited to the business's own assets, as long as each entity keeps separate accounts and written agreements.

Different people own different parts of your business

If a partner should own part of one location or product line, a separate entity lets them own that piece without a claim on the rest.

You plan to sell one part of the business

A business in its own entity, with its own books, is easier to value and sell on its own.

Your accountant shows savings well above the cost

At higher profit levels, some structures can lower your tax by more than they cost to run. The answer depends on your numbers, so ask for the calculation before you form a new entity.

How to set it up right

PartWhat it looks like
PeopleYour accountant compares the yearly cost with the expected savings. An attorney drafts the operating agreements and leases. You approve each entity once you know its purpose.
ProcessEvery payment between entities follows a written agreement at a market price. You review the structure once a year and close any entity that no longer serves a purpose.
SystemsEach entity has its own bank account and its own books in QuickBooks Online, with a combined monthly report so you can see the whole business together.

Example: An Oakland Restaurant Group

Before: An Oakland restaurant owner ran two restaurants with $4.2 million in combined revenue under one LLC. The owner was buying the building of the first restaurant for $2.1 million and bringing in the second restaurant's chef as a 30% partner. The plan was to put everything into the existing LLC.

The fix: The building went into its own LLC, which leases it to the first restaurant at a market rent of $14,000 a month under a written lease (process). The second restaurant moved into a new LLC, owned 70% by the owner and 30% by the chef (people). Each entity has its own bank account and books, with one combined report each month (systems). The two added LLCs cost about $14,200 a year in California taxes and fees, tax returns, and bookkeeping.

The result: A claim against either restaurant is generally limited to that restaurant's assets, and the chef owns part of the second restaurant without any claim on the building. Three years later, the owner sold the first restaurant and kept the building, which now earns $168,000 a year in rent from the buyer. The structure saved little in tax. Its value came from protecting the building, making the partnership possible, and keeping $168,000 a year of rent after the sale.

Quick Checklist

Answer yes or no to each question.

  • Process: Can you name the asset, partner, or future sale that each of your entities exists to serve?
  • Process: Has your accountant compared each entity's yearly cost with the tax it saves?
  • Systems: Does each entity have its own bank account and its own set of books?
  • Process: Are payments between your entities backed by written agreements at market prices?
  • People: If you have an S corporation, has your accountant confirmed that its owners are allowed to hold S corporation shares?

If you answered no to two or more questions, now is a good time to review your structure, before another year of fees and filings.

Keep reading